Welcome to Picky Cafe
A Little More Picky
Picky isn’t about being difficult. It’s about caring enough to choose well.
We believe good food is worth being particular about. Good coffee is worth seeking out. Local makers deserve our support.
Old buildings deserve a new chapter. Gardens deserve to grow. And neighborhoods are better when people have a place to gather.
So come in. Look around. Ask questions. Tell us exactly what you like.
We’ll help you find it.
Our
Menu
We’re a tiny café, but we have big standards.
Our menu is intentionally small and thoughtfully curated, built around the best ingredients we can find from local farmers, growers, and producers. Because we follow the seasons, what’s on the menu can change from day to day — and that’s part of the fun.
Each morning, we bake and prepare fresh food with the goal of meeting the standards of even our pickiest customers. Stop in for breakfast, lunch, a snack, coffee, wine, or whatever sounds just right today.
Picky’s Market
Forgot the sugar? Need something delicious for dinner? Heading to a picnic and looking for the perfect snack? Searching for a thoughtful gift that doesn’t feel like an afterthought?
Picky’s Market has you covered.
We’ve filled our shelves with the things we think are worth bringing home — from pantry staples and specialty foods to locally crafted goods, seasonal produce, and those hard-to-find little treasures that make a meal, a gathering, or a gift just a bit better.
We’re picky about what we put on our shelves so you don’t have to be.
